Securing our safety
April 19, 2023
After the Robb Elementary school shooting in Uvalde, Texas last spring, Gov. Greg Abbot mandated school safety measures for districts statewide in a letter to the Texas School Safety Center on June 1.
As a result, LISD has established new safety protocols for the 2022-2023 school year.
LISD Director of Safety and Security Matt Garrett said in a statement to the Marquee that the district is working to ensure students’ safety.
“[There] is just nothing more important to us as a district than the safety of all those we serve,” Garrett stated. “We are literally protecting our family when we think about how to best keep our district safe and secure.”
LISD currently observes the Standard Response Protocol as its emergency response plan. It refers to five courses of action in an emergency: secure, lockdown, evacuate, shelter or hold.
In the case of an active shooter inside the school, students and staff should engage the lockdown option.
The district also teaches Avoid, Deny, Defend, a strategy to help teachers avoid the shooter, deny their entrance into the classroom and finally defend students.
Students and teachers are trained to comply with the Standard Response Protocol through regular lockdown drills.
“I think those are smart also,” Mestanza said. “Because when we actually have to end up doing those, the real life situation, we’ll know what to do.”
To Mahns, the best thing the district can do is continue open communication with the students.
“I think just checking in and making sure that we feel safe, and assuring us that they have a plan,” Mahns said.
Locked doors
*All statistics from a poll of over 350 students by the Marquee
A key part of Abbott’s change to school safety is the requirement that all outside doors on Texas schools remain locked during school hours. He has also implemented random checks at every Texas school to check that doors are locked. While keeping the outside doors locked isn’t new on campus, it is being more heavily enforced. Administration checks the exterior doors weekly, and being caught opening a door or letting somebody else inside is punishable with Wednesday night school.
Classroom doors are also expected to be locked during class time. When somebody knocks on the door, teachers check who it is before opening it.
However, in a poll by the Marquee, only 14.6% of students surveyed said that locked classroom doors are effective.
To senior Emily Starks, a system where teachers must pause lessons to let a student into class is a disruption of class time.
“They honestly don’t make me feel safer,” Starks said. “They’re kind of an inconvenience. They disrupt the class a lot.”
However, sophomore Dayanara Mestanza believes that it protects students.
“I think the locked doors is a smart idea because the people who
are unwanted in a classroom, they won’t be able to come in,” Mestanza said.
Mestanza also said that students should respect the rule, no matter their views on it.
“I just think you have to be considerate of other people’s safety and the rules,” Mestanza said.
But while senior Emily Starks understands that the rules are meant to protect the students, she feels like the doors have changed the high school experience.
“It’s also a constant reminder,” Starks said. “It doesn’t freak me out, but it’s kind of like, ‘Oh yeah, we’re always susceptible to school shootings.’”
According to School Board Member Sheila Taylor, the district is walking the line between protecting kids and maintaining a comfortable environment at school. While she approves of locking classrooms, she also understands the less relaxed environment it creates.
“My middle schooler, some of the stuff she says is, ‘It feels like I’m in jail,’” Taylor said. “But, she saw what happened in Uvalde. She’s that age, and she understands what’s needed.”
At the Uvalde shooting, Robb Elementary’s exterior doors and the classroom were both unlocked, allowing the shooter to easily enter the school. The classroom doors could only be locked from the outside.
Garrett said that even though student convenience is an important factor of safety rules, effectiveness is more important.
“I would tell students that while their perspective is always important, we will always put safety over convenience,” Garrett stated.
Sophomore Makayla Mahns supports the locked doors. She said that she likes that teachers vet who enters a classroom.
“Someone can’t just march in without us knowing,” Mahns said.
Emergency Response
LISD currently observes the Standard Response Protocol as its emergency response plan. It refers to five courses of action in an emergency: secure, lockdown, evacuate, shelter or hold.
In the case of an active shooter inside the school, students and staff should engage the lockdown option.
The district also teaches Avoid, Deny, Defend, a strategy to help teachers avoid the shooter, deny their entrance into the classroom and finally defend students.
Students and teachers are trained to comply with the Standard Response Protocol through regular lockdown drills.
“I think those are smart also,” Mestanza said. “Because when we actually have to end up doing those, the real life situation, we’ll know what to do.”
To Mahns, the best thing the district can do is continue open communication with the students.
“I think just checking in and making sure that we feel safe, and assuring us that they have a plan,” Mahns said.
Parent opinion
LISD introduced the Elementary Rover Patrol Program this year, which rotates officers between elementary schools. A new tip line was also created for elementary school families to report suspicious activity and safety concerns.
School Board Member Shiela Taylor said that as a parent, increased police presence on elementary campuses is the most important precaution to her.
“We always had somewhat of a presence, but we didn’t have the assigned school resource officers,” Taylor said. “And now we work with all of the local cities.”
Karen Dooley has two kids in high school, one in middle school and one in elementary. She said that she trusts LISD to prioritize her children’s safety.
“I think they’ve had lots of meetings, used lots of…research to develop protocols to keep our kids safe,” Dooley said.
Parent Kristi David has two high school students and one elementary schooler. She said that she is saddened by the need for police officers to monitor today’s schools.
“I trust those police officers, but I also think it’s incredibly sad…that we have to live in a state where police have to constantly be with our young children,” David said.
David said that she understands locking exterior doors, but does not see the point in locking classroom doors.
“While I understand the need to go to the point where you’re trying to protect your kids, the fact that you guys are going to school behind locked doors inside the building?” David said. “Jeez. It’s a prison.”